Marie Jasmin: Hi. So yes, my name is Marie. I’m a UI design­er in video games. And today I’d like to address the issue of time well spent, in games and beyond, with a very small yet pow­er­ful idea. 

So, imag­ine a per­son emerg­ing from a long play ses­sions in her liv­ing room. She turns off the screen and maybe the room has gone dark, and she’s won­der­ing how three hours have gone by? Often these days we hear peo­ple describe their screen time as a vor­tex. My friend told me the oth­er day, I fell in a YouTube hole,” as an excuse. 

But, games aren’t meant to be pro­duc­tive. How are we to mea­sure time well spent in a prod­uct with an enter­tain­ment com­po­nent? That’s a very sub­jec­tive ques­tion. So, here’s a very per­son­al answer. 

If our play­ers emerge from an expe­ri­ence inspired to cre­ate their own story—to draw, to write, to dress up maybe. Or just to talk about it with friends. To share. If our play­ers feel enriched, trans­formed by an expe­ri­ence. If they form mem­o­ries, fond mem­o­ries, then yes I think the time invest­ed has worth. 

Now, for an expe­ri­ence to be mem­o­rable let alone trans­for­ma­tive, the brain—the human brain—has to be pushed out of default auto-pilot mode into con­scious thought. And that push nec­es­sar­i­ly involves some lev­el of dis­com­fort. Now for the sake of pre­sen­ta­tion, here’s my def­i­n­i­tion of it. Discomfort has four major forms: lack of con­trol, nov­el­ty, unpre­dictabil­i­ty, or threat to the ego. But what it all boils down to is that the brain needs to leave its com­fort zone for an expe­ri­ence to be mem­o­rable. Small moments of dis­com­fort. Not trau­ma, but small moments of dis­com­fort sprin­kled like spice through­out an expe­ri­ence are the birth­place of good sto­ries and fond memories. 

Your every­day design­er knows a lot about dis­com­fort because it is our job to pre­vent it from ever hap­pen­ing. And this includes inter­face design­ers. We are here to make the world a lit­tle more flu­id, a lit­tle more usable, a lit­tle more acces­si­ble. The craft of design is about remov­ing friction. 

But think about it: it fol­lows that if we know the heuris­tics of usabil­i­ty, we know how to vio­late our own rules. We’re dis­com­fort experts. And I have for you today three exam­ples from inter­face design and video games where discom­fort was added on pur­pose for mem­o­rable impact. 

So my first exam­ple is also the first game project I ever worked on. It’s pret­ty old. Assassin’s Creed 2. So for this game, the inter­face design team was tasked with mak­ing the play­er feel like they are inter­act­ing with a machine that is cutting-edge future tech­nol­o­gy that lets you relive the mem­o­ries of your ances­tors. So basi­cal­ly we were told that for nar­ra­tive rea­sons our play­ers need­ed to feel like grand­pa using a remote, a mix of curios­i­ty and insecurity. 

So we vio­lat­ed the rule to match the sys­tem and the real world by pur­pose­ful­ly not using famil­iar terms in our label­ing sys­tem. So the the main menu was called the ani­mus, and the replay menu was called the DNA menu. There is no match in the real world what­so­ev­er for a DNA menu. We knew that our play­ers would just need to click all the but­tons to find out what they did. 

The ani­mus became undoubt­ed­ly mem­o­rable if not quite usable. To my bewil­der­ment actu­al­ly, it still comes up in best game UI lists over ten years after the game’s release, which in game indus­try time is an eternity. 

Here’s anoth­er exam­ple, a pret­ty bold one actu­al­ly. This is the pow­er armor that play­ers will encounter at some points in the Fallout fran­chise. And as its name indi­cates, it pro­vides our play­ers with great pro­tec­tion. Obviously, there are caveats. And here inter­est­ing­ly, one of the major costs of using the armor for the play­ers is a cost in usability. 

So upon enter­ing the armor, the inter­face ele­ments that the play­er is famil­iar with, which are in green in this screen, are com­plete­ly reshuf­fled and the same infor­ma­tion is sud­den­ly pre­sent­ed in a dif­fer­ent way, forc­ing the play­er to expend con­scious men­tal effort to relearn a new inter­face in exchange for a game­play advantage. 

This ele­ment of dis­com­fort makes the choice to use the pow­er armor, or not, an inter­est­ing choice. In fact games often become icon­ic for their abil­i­ty to offer mem­o­rable choic­es that become the basis for peo­ple to cre­ate their own stories. 

My last exam­ple is pulled from the recent cul­tur­al phe­nom­e­non Untitled Goose Game. Here, our play­er is a goose. They walk a bit clum­si­ly. They honk. And they can also bend their necks. The neck-bending con­trol is mapped to the left trig­ger. Meaning that the fin­gers of each hand need to move inde­pen­dent­ly to con­trol dif­fer­ent parts of the goose. This con­trol scheme is usu­al­ly reserved for a bit more advanced play­ers as it can cause strug­gle in casu­al play­ers or children. 

However, in Untitled Goose Game the strug­gle itself is fun; it’s part of feel­ing like a goose. So here effi­cien­cy of use is being sac­ri­ficed on the altar of game feel. It’s very well done. It does feel like a goose. 

I want to take also this oppor­tu­ni­ty to state that any inten­tion­al, pur­pose­ful sac­ri­fice in usabil­i­ty can and should be test­ed in the lab. Like, it’s UX as usu­al. It’s just an extra set of con­straints for which suc­cess cri­te­ria can be estab­lished, mea­sured, and weighed against oth­er goals. 

I can’t help but won­der how all this could apply to inter­ac­tion design beyond video games. Should we all be keep­ing a clos­er watch on the mem­o­rable” met­ric? Can we mea­sure sto­ries cre­at­ed and shared about an expe­ri­ence? Can we rede­fine engage­ment to include emo­tion­al involve­ment? Creative inspi­ra­tion? What should engage­ment become? 

Design is a gar­den of sto­ry­telling. If we fer­til­ize our users with just enough dis­com­fort, their sto­ries will take root and grow.

Further Reference

Interaction 20 web site


Help Support Open Transcripts

If you found this useful or interesting, please consider supporting the project monthly at Patreon or once via Cash App, or even just sharing the link. Thanks.