Jacob: First of all, thank you so very much for hav­ing me tonight. It’s actu­al­ly real­ly dif­fi­cult that I can’t be there in per­son, and I wish that I could be. When Lisa asked me to speak tonight, I actu­al­ly did­n’t feel that I had some­thing to say until I sat down and wrote a text. So I’m just going to read you a text, and as a result I’m going to cov­er my cam­era because there’s noth­ing worse than watch­ing some­one read. So. As you can see there it’s just a bright white light, and now I’m going to read you this text, and I hope that you can still hear me.

[Some in crowd chant­i­ng We want Jake.”]

Lisa Rein: Jacob, come back on cam­era, please. Don’t do it, Jake.

Appelbaum: I’m sor­ry. It has to be this way. That’s how it has to be, I’m sor­ry, but here we go.

Rein: It’s okay. No, no, no!

Appelbaum: You can’t fuck­ing be seri­ous. [cross-talk] —ter­ri­ble.

Rein: Jacob, please. Thank you. Jesus Christ.

Appelbaum: Look, I want to see all of you, too, but we don’t get what we want so I’m going to read you this text now.

The first time that I heard Aaron Swartz speak in per­son was at the Creative Commons release par­ty in San Francisco. [cross-talk]

Rein: Jacob, we’re going to turn it [the podi­um lap­top] around.

Appelbaum: I was work­ing the door as a secu­ri­ty guard, if you can believe that. I think it was in December of 2002. Meeting peo­ple in that seem­ing­ly weird world mutat­ed life in a good way. Over the years, we crossed paths many times, be it dis­cus­sions relat­ing to CodeCon, to age lim­its, or free soft­ware, or the Creative Commons, or about cryp­to, or any oth­er top­ic, Aaron was an insight­ful, hilar­i­ous, and awe­some person. 

Aaron and I worked on a few dif­fer­ent over­lap­ping projects and I very much respect­ed him. Some of the top­ics that came up were light, but some were very heavy and very seri­ous. The top­ic of WikiLeaks was impor­tant to both of us. In November of 2009, long before I was pub­lic about my work with WikiLeaks, I intro­duced Aaron to some­one at WikiLeaks who shall remain unnamed. If we had a secure, easy way to com­mu­ni­cate, if some sort of com­mu­ni­ca­tion sys­tem had exist­ed that had reduced or elim­i­nat­ed meta­da­ta, I prob­a­bly could’ve done so with­out a trace. 

But we did­n’t. You’re not the first to know, the FBI and the NSA already know. Less than a year lat­er, Aaron sent me an email that made it clear how he felt. That email in its entire­ty was straight­for­ward and its lack of encryp­tion was inten­tion­al. On July 10, 2010 he wrote, Just FYI, let me know if there’s any­thing, ever, I can do to help WikiLeaks.” Did that email cast Aaron as an ene­my of the state? Did Aaron wor­ry? 2010 was an extreme­ly rough year. The US gov­ern­ment against every­one, the inves­ti­ga­tion of every­one asso­ci­at­ed with WikiLeaks stepped up. So many peo­ple in Boston were tar­get­ed that it was effec­tive­ly impos­si­ble to find a lawyer with­out a con­flict. Everyone was scared. A cold wave passed over every­thing, and it was fol­lowed by hard­ened hearts from many.

In February of 2011, a few of us were at a par­ty in Boston host­ed by danah boyd. Aaron and I walked a third per­son home, a third per­son who still wish­es to remain unknown. The sense of para­noia was over­whelm­ing but pru­dent. The over­bear­ing feel­ing of com­ing oppres­sion was crush­ing for all three of us. All of us said that our days were num­bered in some sense. Grand juries, loom­ing indict­ments, threats, polit­i­cal black­list­ing. None of us felt free to speak to one anoth­er about any­thing. One of those peo­ple, as I said, still wish­es to remain unnamed. We walked through the city with­out cross­ing cer­tain areas because Aaron was wor­ried about being near the prop­er­ties that MIT owned. 

When Aaron took his life, I remem­ber being told by some­one in San Francisco, and I did­n’t under­stand. I lit­er­al­ly did not under­stand who they’d meant or who it could be. It seemed impos­si­ble for me to con­nect the words that were com­ing out of their mouth with my memories.

Shortly after Aaron was found, WikiLeaks dis­closed three facts:

  • Aaron assist­ed WikiLeaks.
  • Aaron com­mu­ni­cat­ed with Julian and oth­ers dur­ing 2010 and 2011.
  • And Aaron may have even been a source.

I do not believe that these issues are unre­lat­ed to Aaron’s per­se­cu­tion, and it is clear that the heavy-handed US pros­e­cu­tion pushed Aaron to take his own life. How sad that he was aban­doned by so many in his time of need. Is it real­ly the case that there was no link? Is it real­ly the case that the US pros­e­cu­tors went after Aaron so harsh­ly because of a cou­ple of Python scripts and some PDFs? No, clear­ly not.

I wish that Aaron had lived, as we all do. This was the year that brought us the sum­mer of Snowden, and yet it felt like ten years of grief in a sin­gle one. It was the last time I’ll spend any time in the US, and even now it feels like a dis­tant mem­o­ry, most­ly bad mem­o­ries. Especially the mem­o­ry of learn­ing about Aaron.

Only a few months lat­er in 2013, there was a New Year’s Eve toast with many of us who were being inves­ti­gat­ed, harassed, and tar­get­ed for our work, our asso­ci­a­tions with WikiLeaks, and for our polit­i­cal beliefs. It was me that stu­pid­ly, stu­pid­ly said, We made it.” But I know it was Roger, and I remem­ber it well, when he said, Not all of us.” And he was­n’t only speak­ing only about Aaron, but him too. And it was heart­break­ing to remem­ber, and it was telling of how to cope, how some try to for­get, and we do for­get, and that it is impor­tant to remem­ber. Especially right then and espe­cial­ly right there, just as it is here and just as it is right now.

When we learned more details about the US pros­e­cu­tors, we learned that they con­sid­ered Aaron a dan­ger­ous rad­i­cal for unspec­i­fied rea­sons. One of the pri­ma­ry rea­sons is prob­a­bly the Guerilla Open Access Manifesto. This is a good doc­u­ment, and as many oth­ers I respect it and I admire it. The Guerilla Open Access Manifesto is not as rad­i­cal as the US pros­e­cu­tors might con­sid­er it. But their fear is telling, so let us say it out loud: we should hon­or it and we should extend it.

Let’s not only lib­er­ate the doc­u­ments of the world, let us act in sol­i­dar­i­ty to lib­er­ate all of human­i­ty. Let us cre­ate infra­struc­ture that resists mass sur­veil­lance. Let us enable peo­ple to leak doc­u­ments. And let us also work to infil­trate those orga­ni­za­tions that betrayed us. There is a divi­sion of labor, and we all bring dif­fer­ent skills to the table. Let us all use them in ser­vice of a bet­ter world, in ser­vice of justice. 

We must have total trans­paren­cy about the inves­ti­ga­tion into Aaron. Why was the Department of Justice grind­ing their axe with Aaron? Was it real­ly because of JSTOR and the past anger about PACER? That is absurd and unbe­liev­able. It is dis­pro­por­tion­ate and it is unjust. 

One con­crete thing that needs to hap­pen is for the FOIA case to be prop­er­ly resolved. We must find a way to speed up the pro­cess­ing about FOIAs regard­ing Aaron. Rather than hun­dreds of doc­u­ments at a time, we should have all 85,000 at once and not medi­at­ed by MIT, who is par­tial­ly respon­si­ble for the out­come we have today.

And we must not drop the pres­sure. If you are invit­ed to MIT, I encour­age you to decline and to explain that you do so because of MIT’s treat­ment of Aaron Swartz. Not just Aaron, but those like Star Simpson and Bunnie, who MIT would’ve loved to be like Aaron if the cards had played a lit­tle differently. 

Here are some things you can do to sup­port the lega­cy and spir­it of Aaron. We can sup­port the devel­op­ment of some of Aaron’s projects like SecureDrop. Kevin, Garrett, Micah, and oth­ers are car­ry­ing that torch with, they’re still with us today. You can come and work with many peo­ple at the Tor Project on Tor Browser and Tor Messenger and oth­er soft­ware to be of use to dis­sem­i­nate and to push out infor­ma­tion, impor­tant infor­ma­tion to peo­ple that might have oth­er­wise not hap­pened with­out that soft­ware. And you can come and help us make few soft­ware for free­dom, just as Aaron did.

And there are oth­er projects that need assis­tance. OnionShare, Let’s Encrypt, GlobalLeaks, Pawn[?], Subgraph, Signal, the Transparency Toolkit, and many more.

But it isn’t just soft­ware. There are so many things that can be done. You can write to pris­on­ers of con­science of Aaron’s gen­er­a­tion, of my gen­er­a­tion, of your gen­er­a­tion. Do Jeremy Hammond, Barret Brown, and Chelsea Manning have to die before we work to cor­rect the injus­tices that they face dai­ly? We can and we should free them.

Here are some things to sup­port each oth­er dur­ing the hard times, those with us now and those sure to come in the future. We should sup­port WikiLeaks, and orga­ni­za­tion under attack for pub­lish­ing infor­ma­tion in the pub­lic inter­est. We should sup­port the EFF. They sup­port peo­ple who arethe edge. We should sup­port the ACLU. When oth­ers called Edward Snowden a trai­tor, the ACLU gave him legal sup­port. We should sup­port the Courage Foundation. They are the ones that helped Edward Snowden to seek and to receive asy­lum and do the same with oth­ers that are direct­ly under threat today and those under threat tomor­row. And we should sup­port the Library Freedom Project. They work to edu­cate, to deploy, and to resist, by deploy­ing alter­na­tives in pub­lic spaces for every­one today. And togeth­er, we are already build­ing, deploy­ing, sup­port­ing, and using infra­struc­ture which is nor mere­ly a mat­ter of protest but is an act of resis­tance in itself by being a prac­ti­cal alternative. 

There is a legal les­son that we actu­al­ly must learn in a very hard way, as many com­mu­ni­ties have learned it already, and it is one where the lawyers in the audi­ence who rep­re­sent me are already cring­ing from what I’ve said but they’ll cringe hard­er next. We must resist grand juries. We must not bow down. We must band togeth­er. And togeth­er we can refuse to be iso­lat­ed. We must resist it every step of the way, nev­er giv­ing them any­thing, ever, at all, when they wish to per­se­cute us for our polit­i­cal beliefs. And if you feel there is no oth­er choice, drag it out and make it public.

Consider that the core of Aaron’s lega­cy is not sim­ply about infor­ma­tion or about writ­ing soft­ware. It is about jus­tice, about fair­ness through trans­paren­cy, through account­abil­i­ty, through con­sid­er­a­tion. So then let us con­sid­er our empire and most of all we must con­sid­er our com­plic­i­ty. It is up to us to act and to change things, to fight for the user but also to con­sid­er the world in which he lives. To think as tech­nol­o­gists, but to think far beyond only the tech­nol­o­gy and into our com­mon[?] humanity.

How is this les­son applied to gen­der and racial equal­i­ty? Aaron was­n’t a big­ot, he was thought­ful. He was not a homo­pho­bic per­son, he was accept­ing. He was­n’t a racist, he was unprej­u­diced. Aaron was kind and com­pas­sion­ate. He fought for free speech. He worked and he sup­port­ed your anonymi­ty direct­ly with actions, and he worked to free our cul­ture’s knowl­edge. We must be forward-thinking, not just about one or two bat­tles, not just about one or two legal cas­es. Rather in a broad­er sense, towards a move­ment of move­ments. The Internet is a ter­rain of strug­gle and it will help shape all of the oth­er ter­rains of strug­gle to come, and Aaron helped to shape that ter­rain for us, so that we could shape it for others.

Part of what Aaron car­ried was an under­stand­ing that it was­n’t just that some­thing need­ed to be done. He car­ried with him the idea that very spe­cif­ic things need­ed to hap­pen, and for very good rea­sons, to ben­e­fit all of those alive and all of those yet to live. He cared deeply about free soft­ware, and he cared deeply about the free cul­ture move­ment. He worked to advance many oth­er issues. Let us car­ry on that work, what­ev­er the cost, wher­ev­er they may take us. 

Aaron was head­strong and hilar­i­ous. He was young. Today he would’ve been 29. Use your time wise­ly. May you have more time than him, and may you use it as wise­ly as he did. 

Good night.

Further Reference

The Aaron Swartz Day web site.

Help Support Open Transcripts

If you found this useful or interesting, please consider supporting the project monthly at Patreon or once via Cash App, or even just sharing the link. Thanks.