Georgina Voss: So, I don’t remem­ber the first time I went online. It was kind of always there, real­ly. There was a point— Well not always there. There was a point when it was­n’t and then there was a point one day when the com­put­er in my dad’s study sud­den­ly had the Internet on it. And it was big, and bricky, and the things we print­ed out from it were slow and bricky. And it was kind of there. So it was­n’t a big excit­ing event real­ly, because the pos­si­bil­i­ties of it nev­er grabbed my brain in the same way that I got the excite­ment—overwhelm­ing excite­ment of get­ting my first text mes­sage. That was thrilling. The Internet kind of just…was­n’t, real­ly.

So I used it a bit for work. I used it as as an under­grad­u­ate. It was nice to know a web site was there, but the web sites were nev­er of the amaz­ing capac­i­ty and speed that they are now. What I find use­ful now cer­tain­ly did­n’t exist fif­teen, twen­ty years ago at all. 

The real­iza­tions I have now of oh my God you know, I can find as many pic­tures of piglets wear­ing cow­boy hats as I want, I did­n’t real­ly even have then. I just had like kind of…[inaudi­ble] imag­i­na­tion around it. And I did­n’t in the begin­ning find it par­tic­u­lar­ly use­ful for social stuff either. We had at uni­ver­si­ty a very kind of…early, lumpen email sys­tem. But because it was a uni­ver­si­ty sys­tem we could all find each oth­er through the uni­ver­si­ty by our tag names, our user­names. And they had this thing called fin­ger­ing. So if you fin­gered some­one’s user ID, you could see when they lost logged on. And obvi­ous­ly this was a recipe for heart­break and angst and dra­ma in ways you could­n’t even imag­ine if you were pur­su­ing some­one and you sent them an email and they did­n’t respond. You could tell when they’d last logged on. You know, if you’d bro­ken up with some­one it was you know… I can’t think of any­thing more designed for 18, 19, 20 year-olds drunk on angst in the com­put­er room at three in the morn­ing than what they’d developed. 

And I was also not par­tic­u­lar­ly into games as well, either. So a lot of sto­ries that my friend have about how they stayed up to 3:00 AM in the col­lege com­put­er room play­ing this or that game, that just was­n’t a space I inhab­it­ed. So I don’t think I was meant to be one of those ear­ly pio­neers, or at least what was built was­n’t built for a pio­neer like me.

I poked around in some of the ear­li­er online mes­sage boards. A lit­tle bit, because the anonymi­ty of it actu­al­ly just made it kind of strange and too fast-moving for me and I could­n’t quite get my hook to it, in a way. And then mes­sage boards came along. And they were a lit­tle bet­ter because you need­ed to have longer post­ing and it was a lit­tle more…to me a lit­tle more inti­mate. And there was one in par­tic­u­lar that a lot of my friends were on. But again, I end­ed up read­ing, you know. I was look­ing at what they were say­ing a lot more than actu­al­ly engag­ing with them­selves. And that was part­ly because I think and write quite slow­ly. My brain might be quite sharp and spiky in places, but when it comes to trans­lat­ing that into a writ­ten response, I’m very very slow. And by the time I’d read what my friends were talk­ing about, and par­tic­u­lar­ly of my friends who were a lot more engaged in music and cul­ture than I was, and when they’d been talk­ing about this album or that cul­tur­al or polit­i­cal point, or this thing about queer the­o­ry, by the time I’d kind of thought of this three-line com­ment that I want­ed to say, the con­ver­sa­tion would’ve moved on quick­ly, and I just… you know. And the struc­ture of the mes­sage boards nev­er real­ly gave you a space to actu­al­ly say, I don’t want to com­ment down at the bot­tom of the thread, I want to come in and com­ment at the top of the thread here.” But I can’t do that now. It was all very much kind a lin­ear drop drop drop drop system. 

The oth­er thing about that was the mate­r­i­al nature of engag­ing online. To do that at that stage, you need a big heavy com­put­er in front of you. I did­n’t own one. This was the stage where lap­tops to me as a post-graduate stu­dent in the ear­ly 2000s were pro­hib­i­tive­ly expen­sive. I knew one per­son in col­lege who had one, and he was way ahead of all the rest of us. And a net­worked lap­top at that. 

And I was also doing a type or work which meant that I was­n’t in front of the Internet all day like a lot of my friends were who were either under­grad­u­ates or had jobs which enabled them to be online all day so they could have one screen open where they were doing their work doing copy­writ­ing or they were writ­ing their essays, and then anoth­er screen open where they were con­stant­ly engag­ing with this chat about you know, Have you seen this film,” or about this point here, blah blah blah. 

And I did­n’t. I would get the com­put­er room at col­lege every—even every few hours was­n’t enough. It was­n’t con­stant engage—all this talk of you know, con­stant [inaudi­ble] and being in this brave new dig­i­tal cyber world, you know. I kind of checked in on my cyber world like every four or five hours but then had to check out again, or then had to leave the com­put­er room and go off cam­pus to go home. So I’m aware this is kind of you know, quite a tiny vio­lin, but it just…that thing, that belong­ing, I’d nev­er real­ly felt it. 

And then, I think it would’ve been about ear­ly, mid-2003, pos­si­bly before then, I went to a big queer event where a lot of peo­ple already knew each oth­er and were talk­ing to each oth­er, and who had these things called LiveJournals. And that was a ques­tion of the event, of you know, Hi, I’m George.” And they’re, Alright,” and, Are you on LJ? What’s your LJ name?” And this I think was still at the stage where you need­ed an invite to get on. So there had to be that kind of [inaudi­ble] social con­tact, too.

And I liked the peo­ple I’d met there, and I thought well you know, if they’re all com­mu­ni­cat­ing on this thing, then I’ll add that to my kind of list of read­ing and I got myself a LiveJournal. And I knew a few oth­er peo­ple who had them but I’d nev­er real­ly signed up. It just seems like anoth­er form of blog­ging, and I knew peo­ple who had blogs but it was­n’t again quite that same kind of pseu­do­nymi­ty, but not quite, kind of space to talk, but not quite.

And that was that, and sud­den­ly all the things that peo­ple had been say­ing about how online com­mu­ni­ca­tion and engage­ment and rela­tion­ships and all those forms of kind of your life splic­ing into some­one else’s and some­one else’s and some­one else’s across this kind of online plat­form, sud­den­ly that all made sense. I don’t want to say any­thing as cliché as like, And that was when I saw in col­or,” because you know, it real­ly was­n’t like that at all. It was still…back in 2003 it was still rea­son­ably clunky…you know, we had a lim­it­ed amount of icon pic­tures we could upload. A lot of the LJ tags were still quite crunchy. It crashed a lot. 

But it was bril­liant. It was fan­tas­tic. It was a space where instead of just hav­ing to write a quick response, you could write a real­ly real­ly long, con­sid­ered post. It was a space where if you were like me and some­one who thought long and hard before writ­ing a con­sid­ered com­ment, you could come into an ear­li­er point in the con­ver­sa­tion and insert a com­ment because of a thread­ed com­ment sys­tem, which was aston­ish­ing and real­ly worked well.

You did­n’t have to just have your one lit­tle kind of han­dle or name that you want­ed. You could have lit­tle pic­tures, you could cus­tomize it. You could make the space your own. And you could also fil­ter the friends that you want­ed to see things. They did­n’t just have to kind of splurge out onto a mes­sage board at 3:00 AM, I hate my life! It’s all so awful.” You could find a small fil­ter for that and splurge that out.

You could make small fil­ters for the peo­ple who were doing aca­d­e­mics at work like you, or who were doing sim­i­lar queer events like you, of who wore sim­i­lar types of hats to you. And then you could find all the com­mu­ni­ties that were out there as well and join those dif­fer­ent com­mu­ni­ties too, and engage in dif­fer­ent ways.

And it felt like it all made sense. And it still kind of aston­ish­es me…and I real­ize you asked me, this is probably—we’re lit­er­al­ly com­ing up to my ten-year anniver­sary on LiveJournal now. I know. And I say I would’ve been 24, 25 when I got my first LJ…my only LJ still. And my LJ name, which I’m not say­ing on this—let peo­ple find me—is relat­ed to the fact that it was the year that I start­ed my PhD. And so it was a kind of aspect of…you know, that was how I picked my name.

And I know peo­ple have picked their name and then changed and changed and changed and changed it. But over that ten years, what LJ has which I real­ly had­n’t seen many oth­er spaces do, is allow the kind of change of lifestyle and how peo­ple’s lives evolve and adapt and shift, but still lets me do that in that space, you know. What I talked about on my first post was stuff that—kind of teenage diary stuff that you look back slight­ly with your fist in your mouth and go, Oh my God.” But you have those com­ments and those con­ver­sa­tions still cap­tured in amber to look back on, even if—you know, as I have done, you lock down the ear­li­er part of your LJ so the past few years are only vis­i­ble to your friends. The con­ver­sa­tions have moved on. The trav­el­ing I’ve done, the kind of dif­fer­ent lines of work I’ve gone into, the things which are pri­or­i­ties or are real­ly impor­tant to me now, in some spaces are not nec­es­sar­i­ly the same as they were then. But LJ has kind of enabled all of that and still lets me write long, angsty or thought­ful posts but still lets me get advice from var­i­ous com­mu­ni­ties that I’m in. It’s about as hor­i­zon­tal as it can get as a plat­form. There isn’t that strange thing of kind of Facebook fans sites. It’s just there are peo­ple there and they have their LJs, and that’s what they are.

I think one of the things I gen­uine­ly like most about it, which I’m aware that I might be spoil­ing by talk­ing about this on a pod­cast, in the way that a restau­rant crit­ic says you know, But there’s this one tiny place, and it does the best gnoc­chi you’ll ever have! If I tell you where it is…” and you know, then every­one swarms this gnoc­chi restau­rant and then that’s the end of it, it’s gone. 

What I like about LiveJournal is its stealth, basi­cal­ly. No one thinks it still exists. So Twitter, even if you’ve got a pri­vate Twitter, there’s still kin­da those link­ages that’re there and the pub­lic Twitter’s pub­lic. Facebook is Facebook, you know. All these plat­forms are kind of col­laps­ing into each oth­er like one gigan­tic black hole all suck­ing back to one glo­ri­ous, sin­gle uni­fied iden­ti­ty. And LiveJournal’s like, Oh real­ly, fuck that. Have as many live­jour­nals as you want, you know. Log in how you want to. Call your­selves twen­ty names.” But also it’s the thing that most peo­ple is still not going. It was the thing that peo­ple used five, ten years ago. And they’re like, Oh you still have a live­jour­nal. It’s still around?” Like that dod­dery old man is still walk­ing around the estate? Oh my God.

And that’s great. So yeah, it’s com­plete­ly stealth. People say is it not just pop­u­lat­ed by Russian teenagers? And like yes, yes it is. Don’t come near LiveJournal. Don’t go hunt­ing for us, you know. We might be here if it’s secret.

And that’s in a space where it does feel like there’s this push towards the grand uni­fy­ing iden­ti­ty that allows me to log in every­where, pro­vid­ed that Mark Zuckerberg is hap­py that you’re doing so. LiveJournal just feels like, Aha, well screw that. Log in under what­ev­er user­name you feel will be most apt to you today and that’ll be fine for us.”

I think also as well around the tim­ing of it, it laid the way for obvi­ous­ly a lot of oth­er social media plat­forms. I mean, you’re engag­ing with peo­ple, you’re giv­ing out per­son­al infor­ma­tion, you’re post­ing pic­tures, maybe videos. You’re prob­a­bly get­ting angsty in ways at three in the morn­ing that at nine in the morn­ing aren’t nec­es­sar­i­ly the best idea in the world but you know, what’s done is done.

But LiveJournal I think gave a lot— It cer­tain­ly gave me my train­ing wheels for how to engage oth­er bits of social space. We…people I know on LJ, I think we learnt quite quick­ly (or prob­a­bly some not as quick­ly as we should’ve done) where the lim­its of shar­ing and over­shar­ing are. How pas­sive aggres­sion is man­aged in an online space. What lan­guage you use when you can’t see some­one’s facial reac­tion, and so how you tone down or medi­ate what you’re say­ing in a writ­ten sense so that you can express your­self more ful­ly. Which groups of peo­ple you do and don’t talk to and what infor­ma­tion you share with­in those subsections. 

And so what real­ly struck me when Facebook came along…however long lat­er it would’ve been, five years lat­er, prob­a­bly? Maybe four, five years lat­er. The peo­ple I knew who had LJs, when they migrated—or when they got Facebooks as well, it was a space they knew, and they were fair­ly con­fi­dent in know­ing if they were shar­ing infor­ma­tion, who they would be shar­ing it with, what would be tak­en from that. It was a known quantity.

Whereas peo­ple who came kind of fresh to Facebook, it was just mad­ness. It was kind of like see­ing the dark­er side of someone’s…inside some­one’s head, with no kind of con­trol­ling voice or bound­ary on it. All the peo­ple you’d kind of broad­ly known, school or uni­ver­si­ty friends, sud­den­ly talk­ing about aspects of their life that had they had live­jour­nals they would’ve learnt how to fil­ter out those con­ver­sa­tions but instead it was just a mas­sive splurge of, And then I broke up. And then oh my God this is my par­ents,” and it was just like, No! No! Learn what this plat­form is doing. Learn how you’re trans­mit­ting your­selves on it.

But they had­n’t had that kind of ini­tial train­ing space that I think LiveJournal cer­tain­ly offered for me as a way of kind of nego­ti­at­ing it. And again, I look back at my ear­ly stuff from 2003 now, like I said com­plete­ly locked down, just…with my fist in my mouth. It’s kind of… But I guess I look back at my teenage diaries which are cov­ered in stick­ers also with…you know, with my fist in my mouth just at the kind of lan­guage that I was using. Enormous dra­ma, cap­i­tal D dra­ma, that was being invoked in the name of some­thing or oth­er; get­ting a reac­tion. And that’s adapt­ed and evolved with­in the LiveJournal space. And yeah, I still make use of a bunch of dif­fer­ent oth­er spaces to talk in and con­nect in and do all the oth­er ter­ri­bly dull, SEO, buzzword‑y type things and man­age what­ev­er facet or spike of my iden­ti­ty I need to use for one par­tic­u­lar day or another.

But LJ just, it feels like kind of a safe, stealthy, under­ground, bot­tom line that can be relied on. Actually some­thing a bit more…if not authen­tic but you know, clos­er than any­thing else, which is a bit more shouty. 

I think you’d— You’d asked us to all think about what I miss the ear­li­er days… I’m not sure that I do, actu­al­ly. It’s fun­ny, I was doing some read­ing for the book, and also for anoth­er paper I’m writ­ing back on a bunch of papers that were pub­lished around 2002 that was look­ing at this new phe­nom­e­non of new media. And it was talk­ing about things like CD-ROMs, and intranets, and this brave new space we’d be inhab­it­ing. And the fantastic…you know, what could be built there. And I’d nev­er a part of that con­ver­sa­tion. It felt like— You know, I said I wasn’t…in that group of pio­neers. I’m hap­pi­er now that there’s actu­al­ly a space that has been built up that I feel like I can mod­i­fy what’s there and make it you know…and adopt it to my own desires, rather than hav­ing to try and fight for or engage in a con­ver­sa­tion that I was­n’t equipped with the skills to engage in fif­teen years ago, you know, but I know that stuff now.

Do I miss any of it? Not real­ly. I still go—I mean… Seriously. The moments of won­der I have now are gen­uine­ly things like—exactly like I said ear­li­er of you know, that moment I real­ized I can find a video of that or I can look for a pic­ture of that or I can as a researcher find that thing that how­ev­er many years ago it would’ve been…sixteen years ago in the libraries at uni­ver­si­ty I would’ve had to go to the sci­ence library and pho­to­copy my way through a stack of arti­cles from one of the bio­chem­istry jour­nals. I don’t have to do that any­more. I cleared out one of my desks ear­li­er this week, and ditched a ton of papers from my PhD because I knew I could find them online. That stuff is the mir­a­cle to me. Yeah. I’m kind of—I’m inter­est­ed about what comes next, but I’m not sure that I miss much about what came before.

Further Reference

Episode archive page

Help Support Open Transcripts

If you found this useful or interesting, please consider supporting the project monthly at Patreon or once via Cash App, or even just sharing the link. Thanks.