Intertitle: Briefly describe your most vital con­tri­bu­tions; what led you to become an Internet Hall of Fame member?

Douglas Comer: First I did IP tun­nel­ing back in the ear­ly days of the Internet. I put IP over X.25. It was unusu­al because at the time, peo­ple weren’t doing tun­nel­ing, so it was a new idea. 

Second, before there were ISPs or the NSFNET, I hooked up a lit­tle net­work and I got three schools, Williams College in Massachusetts and Boston University and Rice University in Houston, Texas, and I con­nect­ed them through Purdue to the Internet. 

And third, the most sig­nif­i­cant thing was I wrote a series of books that explained the prin­ci­ples and the pro­to­cols and the archi­tec­ture of the Internet that became run­away bestsellers. 

Intertitle: What are the biggest chal­lenges you had to over­come to achieve suc­cess; how did you over­come them? Was there an aha” moment, a peri­od of impact or a break­through real­iza­tion or a steady flow?

Comer: For the dif­fi­cul­ty I think the hard part was that every­thing was new at the same time. There was new hard­ware. There were new pro­to­cols. There was a new imple­men­ta­tion of pro­to­cols in the oper­at­ing sys­tem. It was actu­al­ly dif­fi­cult to fig­ure out how to build pro­to­col soft­ware in the oper­at­ing sys­tems. We had new appli­ca­tions. Things that…you have to under­stand at the time peo­ple did­n’t use net­works. So every­thing was being done at the same time. You could­n’t just go to the store and buy hard­ware, you could­n’t ask peo­ple how should an appli­ca­tion real­ly work. So, fig­ur­ing it out was the hard part. 

Intertitle: Which peo­ple, expe­ri­ences or devel­op­ments were most cru­cial in your pro­fes­sion­al suc­cess and its impact?

Comer: Well at the time, it seemed to me that every­thing I’d ever done sort of con­tributed to this. As an under­grad I was a physics and math major. We did­n’t have com­put­er sci­ence. So when peo­ple start­ed talk­ing about elec­tri­cal inter­fer­ence and why we need­ed pro­to­cols to han­dle it, it made per­fect sense to me. I under­stood what elec­tro­mag­net­ic ener­gy was and how inter­fer­ence hap­pened. I was a math major as well so when it came time to ana­lyze pro­to­cols, that was easy. You know, you could just apply all the log­ic that you learned in math. 

I had gone to grad school in com­put­er sci­ence. I had become real­ly good pro­gram­mer. So I had writ­ten sys­tems pro­grams. I had learned C, and that was some­thing unusu­al at the time. So I could write pro­to­cols in the oper­at­ing system. 

And I guess the last thing was my hob­by was elec­tron­ics. And you know, as a kid I fig­ured out how to build lit­tle cir­cuits. And that came in handy because as I said ear­li­er, all the hard­ware was brand new. And at one point, we had to hook up a brand new com­put­er to the Internet stuff, we had to hook it up to the ARPANET, and we did­n’t have an inter­face card. You could­n’t just go to the store and buy an inter­face card. 

So we end­ed up get­ting a used com­put­er, hook­ing up our own lit­tle wires and sol­der­ing them. So a grad stu­dent and I sat there sol­der­ing wires. Which, that was great because there were very few com­put­er sci­en­tist who would ever sol­der wires. 

So as I say, it seemed like every­thing just came togeth­er. It was…you know, my entire back­ground was just the right stuff. 

Intertitle: What are your hopes for the future Internet? Your fears? What action should be tak­en now for the best future?

Comer: In terms of hopes I would say I have expec­ta­tions that things will con­tin­ue to get bet­ter in terms of tech­nol­o­gy. We will have faster, more reli­able, ubiq­ui­tous Internet every­where, all the time. The cop­per infra­struc­ture will be replaced by fiber optics and wire­less. And things will become much bet­ter than they are now. So it’s not just hopes, I really…I real­ly expect it to happen. 

In terms of fears. I think the biggest fear I have is that we’re caught in a hor­ri­ble arms race. That right now, we have com­pa­nies try­ing to build secure soft­ware, secure hard­ware, secure prod­ucts. And we have lots of groups try­ing to break secu­ri­ty. Figure out how to break in, fig­ure out— Even the secu­ri­ty research com­mu­ni­ty is in the busi­ness of break­ing in. 

And I have this ter­ri­ble fear that it’s like the old days in the Wild West, you know. The banks would build more con­crete in their walls. They were try­ing to pro­tect the bank hard­er. Harder steel bars to keep peo­ple out. And the ban­dits would just use more dyna­mite. It’s always true that it’s eas­i­er to break things than to make them secure. So, as long as we have just an arms race, the bad guys will keep winning. 

Intertitle: What advice do you have for the next gen­er­a­tion work­ing in your field?

Comer: Let’s see, for research there’s a famous com­put­er sci­en­tist Dijkstra who said all you have to do is find what you can do bet­ter than any­body else, and do only that. Stick to the stuff that you do best. A lot of peo­ple advise every young per­son Work on your weak­ness­es.” I always advise them, Build on your strengths.” Find out what your tal­ents are and build on it. And ignore peo­ple that say you’re not good at this and you should spend time work­ing on that. Go for the strength. 

The oth­er thing I’ll say, and I’ve told many young peo­ple this, is even well-meaning senior peo­ple can give you some very bad advice. When I start­ed the Internet project, two indi­vid­u­als in par­tic­u­lar who sep­a­rate­ly took me aside— These were senior fac­ul­ty. I was an assis­tant pro­fes­sor, I was just start­ing out. And they very father­ly said, You’re throw­ing your career away. This is not a good move for you. You should get out of this.” One of them said point blank, Networking has nev­er been part of com­put­er sci­ence, and nev­er will be. No one will be inter­est­ed in this.”

Of course they were dead wrong and in ret­ro­spect it all seems sil­ly. But they were dead­ly seri­ous. And they were not mean, or being ugly. They were giv­ing me advice that they thought from their expe­ri­ence was sound advice. So I say if you’re a young per­son, if you’re start­ing out, and you’re blaz­ing a trail, senior peo­ple in your area will not be able to under­stand or appre­ci­ate the sig­nif­i­cance of what you’re doing. It’ll just seem com­plete­ly foreign. 

Intertitle: What has sur­prised you most about the Internet as it has developed?

Comer: I nev­er antic­i­pat­ed bad play­ers. I think all of us in the begin­ning were so intent on build­ing the tech­nol­o­gy and mak­ing it work, that we did­n’t assume there would be bad peo­ple using the Internet. So when spam appeared, that both­ered me. And then when peo­ple start­ed using the Internet to do crimes I guess we all knew, any new tech­nol­o­gy will be used by crim­i­nals. But still, it just seemed completely…you know, out of the range of what I was think­ing. So, that was a huge surprise. 

Intertitle: What are the most pos­i­tive Internet trends emerg­ing today? What are the most wor­ri­some chal­lenges today?

Comer: More peo­ple are get­ting more access to the Internet. And the things that I dis­like most… I dis­like and I fear the way social net­works have pro­gressed. We have lit­tle groups and they rein­force their own…let me say prej­u­dices.” They want to believe some­thing. They find twen­ty oth­er peo­ple who believe it. And they stick in there clique and they don’t lis­ten to any­body else. It’s self-reinforcing and you can get some real­ly bad things going on just because it sounds like every­one you talk to believes it. So, that’s worrisome. 

Intertitle: How do you hope to see the Internet evolve?

Comer: We real­ly can’t tell how things are going to evolve. You can’t pre­dict, in fact I don’t think any of us in the ear­ly days could ever have pre­dict­ed any­thing like what we have now. The good, the bad, and the ugly. The won­der­ful tech­nol­o­gy. The abil­i­ty to go to a store, buy a device and get on the Internet in ten sec­onds. That was all…I don’t know, sci­ence fic­tion of the time. Or it seemed like sci­ence fic­tion. So we could­n’t have pre­dict­ed that. And I don’t think I can pre­dict where things are going. I hope that we will all even­tu­al­ly adopt the Internet as a util­i­ty and reg­u­late its use the way real util­i­ties are reg­u­lat­ed now.

Further Reference

Internet Hall of Fame pro­file

Help Support Open Transcripts

If you found this useful or interesting, please consider supporting the project monthly at Patreon or once via Cash App, or even just sharing the link. Thanks.