Tom McCarthy: Take Abu Ghraib, for exam­ple. Those amaz­ing images that emerged a few years ago. When I saw those, I was remind­ed of this nov­el by Bernard Noël called Le Château de Cène, The Castle of Communion, that came out in 1969. And it’s a kind of—you know…almost obs—well, obscene, porno­graph­ic alle­go­ry of what was going on in Algeria at the time, what his own gov­ern­ment was doing in Algeria. So in the Château de Cène there’s all these kind of scenes of dom­i­na­tion, sado­masochism, rape, etc. 

With the Abu Ghraib pho­tos, you don’t need a Bernard Noël to do it. The sol­diers them­selves are kind of enact­ing those scenes. And you know, on the one hand there’s some­thing absolute­ly repul­sive and dis­gust­ing about it. And on the oth­er hand, I find it almost kind of sub­ver­sive that… Not that they do it, but that these pic­tures kind of emerge into the pub­lic realm. The kind of poetic…truth of the over­all you know…project. The kind of poetic…truth of the over­all you know…project…[chuck­les]…the over­all neolib­er­al mil­i­tary project that was going on at that time just sud­den­ly erupts for all to see.

I’ve been reread­ing Sade recent­ly, The 120 Days of Sodom, which I haven’t read since I was like 22 or some­thing. And what real­ly struck me…it was just a cou­ple of weeks ago. What real­ly struck me about it now is…well first­ly the first sen­tence could have been writ­ten by Agamben, or in fact Naomi Klein, like yes­ter­day. I mean, it says some­thing like It is in the state’s inter­est to main­tain a con­di­tion of ter­ror, so that it can sus­pend all demo­c­ra­t­ic laws and get away with what it wants.” And then the sec­ond sen­tence says And indi­vid­u­als and busi­ness­es that have a foot in the pres­i­den­t’s office can do very well in times like this.” I’m mean…they could’ve just writ­ten Cheney,” you know. It’s incred­i­bly contemporary.

But what is amaz­ing is that— There’s loads of amaz­ing things about Sade. For exam­ple all of the events that take place in it are reen­act­ments. That these per­verts have set up this whole scene, this kind of prison sit­u­a­tion, have peo­ple tell them sto­ries that they then reen­act and embell­ish sex­u­al­ly onto their pris­on­ers. It’s very kind of Abu Ghraib. 

But, what real­ly struck me as I read it was that Sade’s heroes-slash-antiheroes, his lib­er­tine per­verts, are very clear that what they’re doing is crim­i­nal. They go away. To Switzerland. [chuck­les] They sequester them­selves in an inac­ces­si­ble cas­tle. And they’re proud of the fact that what they’re doing is against the state, it’s against the law, it’s against order. Whereas now, almost iden­ti­cal scenes are being enact­ed, not against order but in the very name of order, of jus­tice, of lib­er­ty, of free­dom, by the state itself. It seems we’ve come that far that that total gap has been com­plete­ly closed.

Help Support Open Transcripts

If you found this useful or interesting, please consider supporting the project monthly at Patreon or once via Cash App, or even just sharing the link. Thanks.