Pioneer Works in Red Hook, Brooklyn is a gor­geous sort of art, exhi­bi­tion, stu­dio space that has a lot of inter­est­ing stuff going on. You have fel­lows upstairs that are mak­ing and cre­at­ing art. You have a bunch of bands that play here. It’s kind of an open com­mu­ni­ty space. It’s real­ly cool. And they have been gen­er­ous enough to allow us to host this event and speak to a com­mu­ni­ty that does­n’t usu­al­ly get addressed on these top­ics but that all of us here feel are real­ly inte­gral to being able to build tech­nolo­gies that actu­al­ly respect pri­va­cy, being able to imag­ine what they look like, being able to actu­al­ly cri­tique what the stakes of those tech­nolo­gies are. 

You don’t need a CS degree to know how they impact your life, so how do we start exam­in­ing those impacts and then lead­ing with an under­stand­ing of what we actu­al­ly want to build, how we want to build it, and let­ting the imag­i­na­tive capa­bil­i­ties of all of these peo­ple dri­ve that. The way in which archi­tec­ture and net­work tech­nolo­gies and pri­va­cy inter­sect, there’s a lot of dis­cus­sion around the Internet of Things. We have an archi­tect here who’s able to cov­er like, I am a very well-respected archi­tect but no one tells me about secu­ri­ty or pri­va­cy. I’m sold devices, I build hous­es.” That’s a huge prob­lem area.

We have librar­i­ans talk­ing about…somebody who runs the New York Public Library’s prison library pro­gram talk­ing about the way in which the nar­ra­tive around pri­va­cy and con­sumer tech­nolo­gies does­n’t cov­er the kind of state sur­veil­lance and oth­er privacy-invasive tech­niques that are hap­pen­ing in insti­tu­tions like prisons. 

How would you build the capac­i­ty to say no to cer­tain tech­nolo­gies? Like, I don’t want track­ing in my com­mu­ni­ty. I don’t want pre­dic­tive polic­ing. What does agency look like in that con­text, and how often are the peo­ple who actu­al­ly have to deal with the effects of tech­nolo­gies consulted.

So we have a whole pan­el here about the prob­lem space of encrypt­ed com­mu­ni­ca­tions. We can build things PGP. Other exam­ples that tech­ni­cal­ly work in a kind of vac­u­um, but don’t work the way that peo­ple expect com­mu­ni­ca­tions tech­nolo­gies to work. So what do we need to do to get to a place where we’re actu­al­ly build­ing to the require­ments of humans, not to the require­ments of cryptographers?

One of the things we need right now, we have an area of prac­tice around this tech­nol­o­gy. There are peo­ple who real­ly know how to build it, how to make it, how to think about it in terms of imple­men­ta­tion. We don’t have a cul­ture around this. So what we need is a cul­ture of cri­tique, a cul­ture of design, a cul­ture of imag­i­na­tion. So we can actu­al­ly begin incor­po­rat­ing a much broad­er swatch of think­ing into our devel­op­ment prac­tices. Simply Secure is an orga­ni­za­tion I helped found that I care a lot about and I think is doing great work. I would check out Simply Secure. 

I would also start under­stand­ing that what you want, what you’re con­fused about, what you think is weird about a lot of the tech­nolo­gies that seem to just per­me­ate our lives with­out our per­mis­sion, with­out our understanding…your voice there is real­ly impor­tant in help­ing shape that. You should­n’t feel pre­clud­ed from hav­ing a crit­i­cal view, from hav­ing agency, just because you did­n’t study com­put­er sci­ence at college.

I would look at sim​pl​y​se​cure​.org. They’re an orga­ni­za­tion that’s real­ly try­ing to do this. I would look at a num­ber of the tools that they sup­port. I would look at the work of a num­ber of the indi­vid­ual artists and con­trib­u­tors here. I would look at Open Whisper Systems and their Signal and TextSecure apps. [since com­bined] I would look at Guardian Project. They also make encrypt­ed com­mu­ni­ca­tion technologies.

Help Support Open Transcripts

If you found this useful or interesting, please consider supporting the project monthly at Patreon or once via Cash App, or even just sharing the link. Thanks.